It’s rarely the video. Here’s how to fix your titles and thumbnails.
If your business YouTube channel is stuck at a few hundred views a video, the problem usually isn’t the filming or the editing. It’s what happens before anyone presses play.
YouTube shows every new upload to a small group of people. If they don’t click, it stops showing it. A great video with a forgettable title and thumbnail never gets the chance to be great.
So before you spend more on cameras, lights or editing, look at your packaging: the title and thumbnail together.
The most common thing I see is a thumbnail built by copying whatever is already working in the niche. Same layout, same colours, same big text in the same corner.
It feels safe, but on someone’s home page it just blends in. There’s no reason to pick yours over the five that look identical next to it.
Five thumbnails that follow the niche’s formula, and one that changes a single big thing. Which one would you notice first?
The opposite mistake is designing something so different that nobody can tell what the video is about.
The sweet spot is familiar but different. Keep the things that tell a viewer instantly what kind of video this is. Then change one big thing:
One big change is usually enough. Change everything and you lose the familiarity that makes people click.
If your thumbnail says “5 mistakes” and your title says “5 mistakes”, you’ve wasted half your space. The two should work as a pair.
Together they should create one clear reason to click.
Most channels have one or two videos that did far better than the rest. It’s tempting to write those off as luck.
They usually aren’t. They’re the clearest sign of what your audience actually wants.
Work out what those videos have in common: the topic, the angle, the title structure, the promise in the thumbnail. Then make more videos that tick the same boxes, from a new angle each time.
If your title promises the same advice as every other video on the subject, viewers have no reason to choose yours.
If you genuinely disagree with common advice in your industry, say so. A clear, honest opinion is one of the strongest hooks you have, as long as you can back it up in the video.
Most businesses film first and think about the title and thumbnail at the end. By then it’s too late to shape the video around a strong idea.
If you can’t come up with a title you’d click on yourself, rethink the video before you spend a day shooting it.
Flip it. Write the title and sketch the thumbnail before you film.
That last point matters more than people think. A clickable title gets the view, but the video still has to deliver it straight away. That’s the subject of the next post: how to keep people watching.
I plan, film and edit YouTube videos for businesses in Bristol, the South West and beyond, including titles and thumbnails. If your channel isn’t getting the views your content deserves, see how I work on YouTube or start a project and I’ll give you an honest take.
Practical video advice for business owners. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
Tell me what you need and I’ll get back to you personally within one working day.
Start a project →